[测评]2020年6月市售16款硅脂性能涂抹横测

yappy-avatar

yappy

2020-06-02T08:35:10+00:00

[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-4un5K1yT3cSyx-ix.jpg[/img]
包括平台搭建以及整个东西测试控温以及由30多个钟没睡觉了。
这篇文章我将在6月7日12点之前全部更新完毕。
数据算法以及结果已经汇总和计算过了。
大家拿到手就能直接食用。

已经更新完毕。欢迎分析新的算法。

测试硅脂这件事耗时耗力。希望各位看到且有nga账号的,在评论区多多回复。拒绝白嫖!

感谢各位的支持。所有东西除了EK硅脂是白嫖的之外全部自费购买或者拿朋友的。保证所有测试结果公平公正。但是误差难免
我专门后来会介绍如何调控误差的并且带上原始数据
有数学或者统计学经验的能帮忙提供更好算法公式我将不胜感激

[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-bse2ZpT3cS289-1hb.jpg[/img]

即将来到了2020年的618。因为经常换机的我。硅脂又不够用了。我个人一直用的是7921等产品。无意间论坛群里问了一下。大家对硅脂效能,其实争议还是比较大的。刚好前段时间。Ek提供了他们家新出的硅脂。本次将测试市面上18种硅脂。话不多说。看测评。


写在最前
本次测试产品选择,由讨论区帖子大家推荐而来,产品测试保证公正客观。算是将会对散热效能。性价比。挥发性等进行考量。因为有平台差异以及个体差异。如何购买需要自行分析。

感谢安钛克提供的海王星 360一体式ARGB水冷
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-fgedK1nT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

目录:
一 测试平台
二 测试条件
三 原始数据
四 外观以及硅脂涂抹
五 结论
六 数据截图


一 测试平台
CPU 10700K
主板 七彩虹Z490
内存 芝奇3200C14 8G
散热 安钛克海王星 360一体式ARG水冷
显卡 XFX RX580
电源 EVGA 1300G2
软件 AIDA64 V625 HWIFNO V6.27
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-itZ1aT3cS4mo-334.jpg[/img]


二 测试条件

二 测试条件
1平台功耗以及环境
CPU 设置 4.6G1.25V 功耗在140W左右

2室温
空调控制稳定温度为22°C(±0.2°C)将会在房间设一个固定测温点以避免误差,每次测试后保证室温恒定后再继续下一轮测试。最终测试结果会在读数以及室温进行略微修正。

3测试方法
测试使用AIDA64进行FPU单烤。
FPU 20min后记录数据 并且记录测试前后室温变化求平均值
涂抹难度以及粘稠度为涂抹时主观感受。
拍照记录保留每次涂抹和拆卸时硅脂样式。

4参测产品以及单价
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-hty9K10T1kScu-cq.jpg[/img]
注:因为硅脂根据量不同单价会有变化,本表取最小分装售价并且旗舰店活官方店报价为基准,仅供参考。

5涂抹逻辑
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-fq9pK19T3cSvm-jd.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
采用DELL官方说明书介绍方式涂抹整个顶盖。


三 原始数据分享
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-avaZ1qT3cS1dh-f2.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
yappy-avatar

yappy

四 外观以及硅脂涂抹

EK TIM 8A[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-k34iK2eT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jslbK2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kk6uK2dT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

信越7868[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jxcgK2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jsbhK2nT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-k3lmK1xT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

信越7921[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-ksjbK2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jspiK2bT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kk3oK2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

GTG8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jrcdK2kT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kjwbK2aT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jdydK24T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TF7[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-3g85K2gT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-84aaK2gT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-gwezK2bT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TF8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-ld1eK2gT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-8w6sK2hT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-dnd0K2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

暴力熊[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-1bjgK28T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-l52lK2cT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
暴力熊拆卸忘了拍照了2333.十分抱歉

MG 8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j2c3K23T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kl0vK27T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kt88K2sT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

G1010[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j0tdK1xT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-k4byK2iT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kkqmK2hT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

MX4[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jt8vK2dT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kl0oK27T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jtenK2cT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TC5888[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-la2uK1uT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jrahK27T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-kkp9K2nT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

NDC[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-3hppK2gT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-bpb9K2cT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-g833K2hT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

GD900[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jiddK24T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j1jsK23T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-ksodK2lT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W13[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-163jK2bT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-5yhpK2bT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-erg9K2oT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W15[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-k331K28T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-6uryK2hT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-bg7pK2jT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W15pro[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-hfjsK28T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-gbfqK23T3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-khzjK2fT3cSsg-iy.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
yappy-avatar

yappy

五 结论
测试初期也有很多大佬跟我商量过用恒温台或者是其他工业设备测试,利用测温设备测试散热器温度等,也有很多人推荐用10900K烤鸡在300W左右以在较高温度测试避免误差。也咨询过大佬,大佬也给我讲解了DTS精度数据对于测试结果的干扰。

但是,我选择了这种测试方式。
分享下我的考量因素:
1大多数人并不会天天满载烤鸡,同样的我觉得用10900K人数在整个CPU圈中也是居于少数的。选择了46X跑FPU 测试功耗稳定140W左右主要是考量了,大多数日用和游戏下实际CPU功耗区间。10700K其实可以跑到200W左右,但是我个人觉得打游戏(大多数)和日用可能很难跑到200W左右的高温,同样140W左右也能给10600 或者其他U做一个参考。
2实际用1200平台测试,更能体现在该顶盖下实际效能表现。TR4以及X299和AM4我都也有,但是我觉得相对来说受众没有1200平台更适合,AM4这一带不是众生平等么。TR4还有X299我觉得并不是能代表大多数玩家23333

因为毕竟是家庭条件,每次测试以及等待环境温度趋于稳定才测试的。但是因为整个流程较长,我用了十多个小时才测试完成。空调虽然一直22°C但是还是收到整个外部环境温度以及昼夜差异偏差影响。所以结果仅供参考。原始数据分析给大家,大家可以根据自己的考量进行不一样的算法得出不同结论。

1涂抹难度
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-1az7ZfT1kSc8-f9.jpg.thumb.jpg[/img]

2三种算法排名
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j2p1K1yT3cSsg-8o.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j7f2K1xT3cSsg-8o.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jgl6K1xT3cSsg-8o.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]



3总结
根据上面三种算法排名,把排名相加,数字越小性能相对越强。
[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-19rgZfT3cS14e-li.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
yappy-avatar

yappy

六 数据截图
数据已经折叠,为了方便阅读。有需要的可以自己展开领取。点开放大
信越7868[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-336hZcT3cSsg-fl.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]
点击展开 ...
信越7868[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-336hZcT3cSsg-fl.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

信越7921[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-8irtZcT3cSsg-ft.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

GTG8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-il1sZdT3cSsg-fq.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TF7[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-a8reZcT3cSsg-fs.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TF8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-j0l8ZdT3cSsg-fs.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

暴力熊[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-b9zkZdT3cSsg-ft.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

MG 8[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-56acZcT3cSsg-fq.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

G1010[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-rcqZdT3cSsg-fv.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

MX4[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-e328ZdT3cSsg-fu.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

TC5888[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-jpnbZcT3cSsg-fo.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

NDC[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-1d34ZcT3cSsg-ft.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

GD900[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-9pr1ZcT3cSsg-fq.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W13[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-6hrjZdT3cSsg-fp.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W15[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-fdnhZcT3cSsg-fp.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

W15pro[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-2h2uZdT3cSsg-fu.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

EK TIM 8A[img]https://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_202006/06/9aQ5-e1p3ZdT3cSsg-fs.jpg.medium.jpg[/img]

各位的祝福都收到了,谢谢各位的支持很开心大家能提出各种建议。

因为个人失误原因模棱X tfx在这类产生了遗漏,十分抱歉。
下次将带来更加准确的温控 更加专业的涂抹方式 以及更加精准的测试。
我会选取其中目前优胜硅脂并加入魔冷X tfx进行250-300w(这个到时候具体定)烤鸡测试
敬请期待。
MoscAMillion-avatar

MoscAMillion

mark[s:ac:茶]
Twhy-avatar

Twhy

插眼zsbd
Ante-avatar

Ante

厉害,有心折腾的人值得鼓励!
CLAF-avatar

CLAF

插眼[s:pg:满分]
themaddpanda-avatar

themaddpanda

插眼了,马上会用到的东西!不知道有没有信越上榜
Gotobu4-avatar

Gotobu4

能不能用个目录
badhitman-avatar

badhitman

支持支持zsbd
I am McLovin-avatar

I am McLovin

虽然我用着30块钱30g包邮的hy883,但我还是得顶一下的[s:ac:哭笑]
Plutonium-avatar

Plutonium

正好看看
ambharish-avatar

ambharish

mark[s:ac:闪光]
BrownFalcon-avatar

BrownFalcon

插个眼,看看7921有没有传说的这么nb
・₊利利.-avatar

・₊利利.

[s:ac:羡慕]坐等详评
GrandMaster Belial-avatar

GrandMaster Belial

Mark了,大佬nb[img]http://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_201209/14/-47218_5052bc80140e3.png[/img]我笔记本用了两年了,正想着是不是拆机清清灰换下硅脂呢[img]http://img.nga.178.com/attachments/mon_201209/14/-47218_5052bd27520ef.png[/img]
YeSUS-avatar

YeSUS

支持大佬
虽然我只用得起散热器附带的硅脂。
watersocks-avatar

watersocks

马克看看